This is a great manipulative graph. Not just because of the scale.
There are 3 clever tricks in this chart, and it’s almost admirable how well-crafted the illusion is.
There are 3 clever tricks in this chart, and it’s almost admirable how well-crafted the illusion is.
I’m fully in the camp that search behavior is changing. More people are turning to ChatGPT, Perplexity, and other AI tools instead of Google to get answers.
But I can’t help but demystify the manipulation behind this graph:
🧠 Trick 1: The Scale The Y-axis zooms into a narrow range, exaggerating small percentage changes. It makes a mild dip look like a free fall.
📈 Trick 2: The Formula What you’re seeing here is Google’s traffic share vs. Bing + ChatGPT, calculated using the formula:
A / (A + B)
Where: A = Google traffic B = Bing + ChatGPT traffic
Seems fair? Not really. Here’s the trick:
When B grows rapidly (and it is), the denominator (A + B) grows faster than the numerator (A). Even if A (Google) remains stable, or even grows slightly, the “share” declines sharply.
You could swap Google with any big website (e.g., Apple, Instagram) and claim Bing + ChatGPT is eating its lunch. Or you could swap Bing + ChatGPT with any high-growth site and make it looks like the site is disrupting Google.
🎭 Trick 3: Adding Bing as a Distraction If it were just Google vs. ChatGPT, you’d see Google had almost 100% of the share pre-ChatGPT. That would make the manipulation obvious.
By including Bing, the pre-ChatGPT baseline is pulled down artificially, so the drop looks smoother and less suspicious. A clever way to distract the audience from the manipulation.
This chart makes it look like ChatGPT is eating Google’s lunch. But the reality?
This graph likely came from a genius storyteller in an AI lab, pitching a dramatic story to unsuspecting investors who don’t question the math but love a compelling trend line.
Be cautious of graphs that tell you what they want you to see instead of what’s actually happening.
#GenAI #ChatGPT #AISEO #SEODisruption #DataLiteracy #ChartCrime #SearchRevolution #FutureOfSearch #GoogleVsChatGPT #GEO #AEO
Enjoyed this? Subscribe for more.
Practical insights on AI, growth, and independent learning. No spam.
More in AI Marketing
Axios’ Sara Fischer in conversation with Cloudflare’s Matthew Prince
For the past 20 years, we have benefited from "free" content on the Internet.
AI amazes me from time to time.
Yesterday, I caught up with an old friend from my hometown, Penang.
How to Keep Up with AI Changes in Your Business
Someone asked me this question recently.
💡 Little-known hack to get the most out of Cursor for FREE
If you're using Cursor on the free plan, you will eventually hit the dreaded "servers overload" screen.
DeepWiki: AI-Generated Docs for Any GitHub Repo
If you're using open-source software, one of the most common problems is outdated or poor documentation.
AI Agents are not plug-and-play. 5 ways to add useful skills to your AI agents.
Most of them came thinking AI agents are plug-and-play. Set it up, and it becomes extremely helpful immediately.
Axios’ Sara Fischer in conversation with Cloudflare’s Matthew Prince
For the past 20 years, we have benefited from "free" content on the Internet.
How to Keep Up with AI Changes in Your Business
Someone asked me this question recently.
DeepWiki: AI-Generated Docs for Any GitHub Repo
If you're using open-source software, one of the most common problems is outdated or poor documentation.
AI amazes me from time to time.
Yesterday, I caught up with an old friend from my hometown, Penang.
💡 Little-known hack to get the most out of Cursor for FREE
If you're using Cursor on the free plan, you will eventually hit the dreaded "servers overload" screen.
AI Agents are not plug-and-play. 5 ways to add useful skills to your AI agents.
Most of them came thinking AI agents are plug-and-play. Set it up, and it becomes extremely helpful immediately.